Many folks on the Left are treating the question of whether or not a business should be permitted to refuse services for a gay wedding as a matter of unjust discrimination based upon protected class. Many on the Right are treating it as a matter of freedom of religion. I see both sides, and while I lean strongly towards the free exercise argument I understand the other side’s concern (which I believe to be overblown) about places with “No ______ Allowed” signs in the window.
But as I’ve written and ruminated over the last several days, I’ve found myself drawn to a possible alternate way of accommodating everybody without doing violence to either matters of conscience or allowing wholesale discrimination. It involves other aspects of the First Amendment – freedom of speech and freedom of association. I believe that non-discrimination principles and religious scruples could be respected and accommodated if we applied those additional two aspects of the First Amendment in the matter of gay weddings.
To do this, I want to lay out a couple of principles that are – or ought to be – pretty non-controversial.
The first is that businesses do have the right to engage in speech and expressive conduct, or to refuse to do so – including refusing to do so for hire. For example, if I walked into the local t-shirt printing business and asked them to print three dozen shirts that read “F*ck the Police”, they would be free to tell me to take my business elsewhere because they reject the sentiment or the language used. If I walked into a bakery and asked for a cake decorated with a big marijuana leaf and the slogan “Legalize Marijuana”, no one would dispute that the owner would be well within his or her rights to reject the order on the grounds that they are uncomfortable putting that message on the cake.
The second is that businesses are free to accept or reject business and events which they view as incompatible with their views – for example, a baker who is an active Democrat would certainly be free to refuse to provide a cake for the opening of the new Republican Party headquarters in the county. Similarly, a florist or a photographer is certainly free to refuse to contract to provide their goods and services for a conference being put on by the Boy Scouts because they disagree with their policy of not allowing gay and atheist Scouts (a policy which has been ruled constitutionally protected as a matter of free exercise of religion). In both cases the basis for rejecting the event is the exercise of constitutionally protected civil rights and civil liberties by those holding the events because the business owners does not choose to associate themselves and their businesses with the events because they reject the message being expressed.
Now if you look at both principles above, the issue is a matter of refusing to engage in speech or association because the business owners hold a different view and choose not to communicate messages they reject or have their business associated with those promoting a particular point of view as they promote that point of view. Nobody is denying those individuals service in all contexts, merely in the discrete situation related to the particular message or event. The t-shirt shop will gladly provide member of the anti-police group with shirts that communicate another message. The baker will gladly serve members of the pro-pot group if they want a different cake or a dozen cookies. The restaurateur will gladly provide a table for members of the political group if they come to dine with their families and friends. If a Scout leader wants a dozen roses for his wife or a Scout orders a corsage for his prom date, the order will be gladly accepted. Assuming, of course, that the members of those groups, their families, their friends, and their other associates are willing to have anything to do with the business that turned away the group.
Which leads us back to the gay wedding issue. If one looks at the well-publicized cases of what some call “anti-gay discrimination” in cases involving weddings in the last few years, it has not been an issue of businesses refusing to serve homosexuals at all. In most of the cases the aggrieved customer had long been a patron of the establishment and had a good relationship with the business owner, who knew the customer’s sexual orientation and was quite content to have them as a customer. The problem arose in relation to one – and only one – event, that being providing services for the wedding ceremony and/or reception. In other words, they refused to be a part of the celebration of that which they found offensive to their firmly held beliefs and communication of opposite beliefs, just as each of we found in each of my earlier examples. They are doing that which we allow business owners to do all the time – to pick and choose which public and private events they do not want to be a part of and which speech they will not engage in for hire.
Trackback Information for A Rethinking Of The Cakes/Flower/Photos For Gay Weddings Issue
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blog2.mu.nu/cgi/trackback.cgi/286087Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'A Rethinking Of The Cakes/Flower/Photos For Gay Weddings Issue'.
Comments on A Rethinking Of The Cakes/Flower/Photos For Gay Weddings Issue
wh0cd768173 cheap viagra online viagra cheap Seroquel
|| Posted by KennethPek, February 27, 2017 04:23 PM ||Rhymes With Right - A Rethinking Of The Cakes/Flower/Photos For Gay Weddings Issue
|| Posted by idlhjyslop, March 9, 2018 04:48 AM ||idlhjyslop http://www.g8487gt61zy3b9o14xmy8e26bk2ss6b5s.org/
aidlhjyslop
[url=http://www.g8487gt61zy3b9o14xmy8e26bk2ss6b5s.org/]uidlhjyslop[/url]
The NBA playoffs now for today, have determined the warriors in the western conference and will compete for a spot in the finals quota, knight still don't know who his opponent was.However, even in the face of the celtics or the wizards, presumably knight will be
|| Posted by yeezy boost, March 9, 2018 12:16 PM ||yeezy boost
PayPal Notification URL.
|| Posted by Wholesale Soccer Jerseys Authentic, March 9, 2018 02:57 PM ||Wholesale Soccer Jerseys Authentic
The NBA playoffs now for today, have determined the warriors in the western conference and will compete for a spot in the finals quota, knight still don't know who his opponent was.However, even in the face of the celtics or the wizards, presumably knight will be
|| Posted by lebron 15 ashes, March 9, 2018 05:45 PM ||lebron 15 ashes
The noises and stressful the playoffs."We are eager to match."Owen said.Knight should first game will be on Thursday in east, and before them
|| Posted by yeezy boost, March 10, 2018 05:18 AM ||yeezy boost
Carey - Owen about injury of varese, said it happened out how knight players want to play games."I was about to enter a 5 on 5 game, but after three seconds, varese is injured
|| Posted by kyrie irving jersey, March 10, 2018 08:09 AM ||kyrie irving jersey
For Jordan and gregg popovich comments James never hit back, but just yesterday in the knight's basketball stadium set aside a James training video, far look like illusions emerged both Owen, a carefully look just know is James
|| Posted by kyrie 2, March 11, 2018 08:48 AM ||kyrie 2
Draft of the same year on the bottom rookie will be what?In general the draft should be able to blow the other party, who would have thought them took Owen on the 60th pick small Thomas in the same year, he turned out to be in the position of the challenger?
|| Posted by nike pg 2, March 11, 2018 09:58 AM ||nike pg 2
Carey - Owen about injury of varese, said it happened out how knight players want to play games."I was about to enter a 5 on 5 game, but after three seconds, varese is injured
|| Posted by canada goose, March 11, 2018 01:02 PM ||canada goose
Yesterday, the wall on the right side 45 live a miserable life in the three points must win.The shooting location is Owen puts up the location of the many times.Today was asked Owen saw wall dead there is what feeling
|| Posted by kyrie irving shoes, March 11, 2018 04:13 PM ||kyrie irving shoes
Post a comment